I am now in the middle
of chapter 11 ("Signing") and still really enjoying it! I like the
evolution and transformation of Donna's character growing up from the immature
high schooler to a young adult. I like the way you describe her internal
world; it's so obvious that things are changing for her and new ideas beginning
to take shape, but even she is a little unsure of exactly what form her new
views, new life etc will take, so while the change itself is imminent and
clear, it's also a bit nebulous and unclear, and you do a good job of conveying
her own confusion with what direction she sees her life going. Especially
the way she questions the lifestyle she has adopted, the agenda of the
"revolutionaries," reflects on the morbidity of the music icons
succumbing to their self-inflicted doom - it's like she wants to be part of the
change and the revolution, but she herself is a bit skeptical of it, a bit wary
of whether that is really what is taking place or not.
It's neat, and again,
I personally can relate to it so much, because when I lived in Berkeley &
Oakland, I too was doing a lot of partying and experimental behavior, and for a
long time I enjoyed telling myself I was adventurous, experimental, a free
spirit, etc. I believed I was growing and evolving. But then there were
times I'd have thoughts creep in that would question that ideology and
challenge it, and would ask myself was I not just being self indulgent, and perhaps
self destructive? So I think you do a really good job of conveying
that inner conflict and confusion for Donna.
I also have been in
similar sort of "love triangle" situations in the past where drugs
and alcohol were involved, and nothing felt off limits, and if there were two
guys I was hanging with, I didn't have to choose between the two, but could
have them both treat me like a queen (how Donna likes Dave and Shell) as a
"package deal"). I appreciate how you touch on this without
depicting Donna as weak, and without making it about her objectification or
exploitation. Rather, it being HER choice to engage with them in this
way, and it being a mark of sexual empowerment. I especially like the
part at the top of page 100, where it says it "must have maant that she
was very special." And talks about her bed pampering her and also being
her theater to perform in. I often felt this way in my own life, that the
indulgences I was making in my romantic/sexual life were MY choice, and I was
choosing to be pampered, loved, adored, and enjoyed being the star of the
show. Looking back, there was definitely a lot of immaturity and hedonism
involved in my behavior and lifestyle, but I don't regret any of it, and I
think they were important experiences to have. There was just something
really relatable there for me that I was impressed you were able to capture and
convey.
I enjoyed the return
to Sally's character and the sequence of events that leads her to enlisting as
a military nurse. That whole section was very auspicious, like there was
something propelling her life to that point (destiny, fate?). The whole
scene with her parents walking in on her & Dawn, the sense of mortification
and shame that produces this need to escape; then slipping out the window was
like (for me) sort of symbolic as her going through a portal of sorts to
another world/reality. When she jumped out the window, "into the
cool of the quiet backyard," I felt intuitively that something big was
going to change for her. I didn't know what, but it was like something
had shifted and there was this propulsion I could feel, the conflict inside of
her, the need for something new/different, the need to escape or be
hidden/saved from having to face her parents, and therefore the reality of her
sexuality and her failing grades. I LOVE all of your descriptions of the
various things happening around her as she walks through the
neighborhoods. Really great descriptive language and imagery on pages
114-116. All of it just so perfectly depicts the urban scene, but also
reflects her internal world. And just the moments leading up to her
bumping into the Army Sergeant, up until the moment she meets him, I thought
all of that was really well done. In that moment he almost seems like a
mythical character, like some fairy godfather of sorts who has come to rescue
her and pluck her from her miserable situation and give her an out. It's
perfect. Wherever someone may fall ideologically in terms of the military, the
war, etc, in that moment, on a personal level, it just seems so clearly the
right choice for her to get out of the rut she's in and move forward with her
life.
I hope that was not
too convoluted and made sense! Basically I just thought that whole section was
really well done, and had a masterful way of pulling the reader along on
Sally's journey.
I have to say,
the paragraphs on pages 121-122 are some of the best writing of the book so
far, in my opinion. You are describing the protest scene, the
"liquid legions of marching revolutionaries." I love
"drift-netting the protean soul" - that's a great line! And the
paragraphs that follow do a beautiful job of capturing not only the physical
scene and surroundings, but also the feelings, moods and emotions of the time.
Really well done!
Comments
Post a Comment